All recent comments on applications from Eurobodalla Shire Council, NSW

8 Kuppa Avenue Malua Bay NSW 2536
Change of use from shop to cafe (Tenancy 1)

This is going to be interesting.
Another cafe? Or is the Sandy Foot expanding?
At least there will be (yet!) another source for our morning coffee.
Add this to the Sandy Foot, the foyer of the Abode Appartments, the Post Office, and around the corner, the Butchers (still the best by the way). And of course the coffee trailer up past the Surf Life Saving Club, and the Food Truck that visits regularly.
Shame to the The Grog Shop go though.

Jeff Allen
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
52-58 Williamson Drive North Narooma NSW 2546
Two lot subdivision

I strongly strongly oppose this development. This is the home of so much of our beautiful wildlife. Every time I drive down here I see the lone little wallabies looking after themselves and the beautiful lyrebirds foraging for food. This is the one bit of habitat they have left. Now the black cockatoos are using these trees also. Leave them some habitat. Not to mention the damage any excavation will have on the stability of the hill, traffic congestion and runoff… save the habitat of thenlyrebird and wallaby. Please do something credible council. NO to this subdivision.

Penelope Maher
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
9/40 Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
Alterations and additions - Internal Fit Out of Small Bar

This would be a complementary addition to the Broulee and MossyPoint food and wine offerings for locals, friends, relatives as well as other visitors to the region.

Mark Berry
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Annetts Parade Mossy Point NSW 2537
16 lot residential subdivision including associated works (associated infrastructure, road works, earthworks and vegetation clearing)

Re. Development Proposal for Lot 16 Annetts Parade

I would like to take this opportunity to express my concern regarding the development proposed -DA0503 / 24 Mossy Point (Lot 16 DP 1248391).

Firstly, I appreciate that the landowner wishes to capitalise on their land asset and acknowledge that they have undertaken several significant studies of the site to meet the requirements of this land classification and other legislation.

To my concerns:

The Conclusion in the Statement of Environmental Effects report states that:

"The material in this Statement of Environmental Effects demonstrates that there will be no unacceptable adverse impact on the amenity or environment of the locality as a consequence of the proposed development."

The NSW Legislation's objectives for the C4 zone, and the consultants' Biodiversity Development Assessment Report (BDAR), both raise points that are at odds with the assertion in the conclusion.

Zone C4: Environmental Living.
Two of the objectives of this zone are:
• To ensure that residential development does not have an adverse effect on those values (special ecological, scientific or aesthetic values).
• To protect the size and shape of vegetation remnants if consistent with the protection of assets from bush fire.

From the BDAR:
1. An endangered ecological community, the Bangalay Sand Forest of the Sydney Basin and South East Corner, is present on the eastern margin of the site. It will not be directly impacted by the proposal, but it is unrealistic to expect there would be no indirect impacts due to including trampling, rubbish dumping, the introduction of pests/weeds, exotic plants, edge effects, habitat fragmentation, and changes in surface hydrology, all of which are associated with the construction of dwellings and hard surfaces, and increased likelihood of human activity.

2. Significant fauna were identified on the site including Grey-headed Flying-fox, Gang-gang Cockatoo, Glossy Black-Cockatoo and Yellow-bellied Glider. The (Vulnerable) Yellow-bellied Glider was recorded within the subject land and critical habitat including sap feeding trees, potential den/breeding trees and movement corridors are "likely to be impacted by the proposed development". Conservation Advice for this species lists threats as population reduction and habitat destruction following the 2019–20 bushfires and continuing population decline due to land clearing, fragmentation, extensive severe fires, and climate change. The proposed impacts map shows several hollow bearing trees and a sap tree located on and bordering the road and house blocks.

The proponent asserts that:

" It is considered that the public interest would best be served by approval of the proposed development, given:
• the absence of demonstrable adverse environmental impacts resulting from the proposal; and
•The social and economic benefits of the proposed development as identified in this Statement of Environmental Effects."

That this assertion has been made in the face of the concerns raised in consulting reports, apparently without community consultation outside of the DA submissions process, is concerning.

Having been here for 17 years, I have seen a progressive removal of native bush and important habitat to meet 'housing demands' - yet have recently seen a disused farm purchased for the purpose of creating housing, which seems much more aligned with sustainability and environmental goals.

I hope you will take the submissions for this project seriously, and in consideration of longer term environmental and sustainability objectives.

Melanie White
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Annetts Parade Mossy Point NSW 2537
16 lot residential subdivision including associated works (associated infrastructure, road works, earthworks and vegetation clearing)

Re. Development Proposal for Lot 16 Annetts Parade

I would like to take this opportunity to express my concern regarding the development proposed -DA0503 / 24 Mossy Point (Lot 16 DP 1248391).

My main concern if the proposed development proceeded would be the impact on the local flora and fauna on this beautiful stretch of land full of beautiful bushland running down to the pristine Tomaga river.

As others have pointed out, the development proposal clearly goes against environmental protection requirements set out in the LEP and DCP for land zoned C4 Environmental Living. It is in no way ‘low impact’ and will have an adverse effect on the local community.

As other have also pointed out, I too sincerely hope that you will uphold our communities environmental standards with regards this and any future development applications. Thank you for taking the time to consider my concerns.

Julie Klugman
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Annetts Parade Mossy Point NSW 2537
16 lot residential subdivision including associated works (associated infrastructure, road works, earthworks and vegetation clearing)

Re. Development Proposal for Lot 16 Annetts Parade

I would like to take this opportunity to express concerns regarding the development proposed -DA0503 / 24 Mossy Point (Lot 16 DP 1248391).

My main concern would be the impact that the proposed development would have on the flora and fauna which currently exist within this area of land. The plot of land, in its’ current state, ensures that many species have a sustainable habitat. The ESC’s own Yellow Bellied Glider policies and practices have not been referred to or adhered to within the application. The Biodiversity Assessment Report which has been prepared for this proposal states that:

“These assessments concluded that a referral under the EPBC Act is recommended for the Yellow-Bellied Glider, given that the species was recorded within the subject land and important habitat including sap feeding trees, potential den/breeding trees and movement corridors are likely to be impacted by the proposed development”.

The impact will most definitely negatively impact not only the Yellow Bellied Glider population but, also the Glossy Black Cockatoos, Gang Gangs and Feather Tailed Gliders who currently dwell and thrive within this area.

The development proposal clearly goes against environmental protection requirements set out in the LEP and DCP for land zoned C4 Environmental Living. It is not ‘low impact’ and will have an adverse effect on the special values we place on an area considered to have ecological and scientific value. Not to mention the aesthetic we pride ourselves on in the ESC - one which values, protects and promotes the natural beauty we have around us.

As a long term resident and part of the local teaching community it saddens me that future generations may be denied the opportunity and privilege of experiencing our areas incredible natural biodiversity as it currently stands.

Thank you for taking the time to consider my concerns, and I sincerely hope that you will uphold our communities environmental standards with regards this and any future development applications.

Clare Dunn
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Annetts Parade Mossy Point NSW 2537
16 lot residential subdivision including associated works (associated infrastructure, road works, earthworks and vegetation clearing)

Re. Development Proposal for Lot 16 Annetts Parade

I would like to take this opportunity to express concerns regarding the development proposed -DA0503 / 24 Mossy Point (Lot 16 DP 1248391).

My main concern would be the impact that the proposed development would have on the flora and fauna which currently exist within this area of land. The plot of land, in its’ current state, ensures that many species have a sustainable habitat. The ESC’s own Yellow Bellied Glider policies and practices have not been referred to or adhered to within the application. The Biodiversity Assessment Report which has been prepared for this proposal states that:

“These assessments concluded that a referral under the EPBC Act is recommended for the Yellow-Bellied Glider, given that the species was recorded within the subject land and important habitat including sap feeding trees, potential den/breeding trees and movement corridors are likely to be impacted by the proposed development”.

The impact will most definitely negatively impact not only the Yellow Bellied Glider population but, also the Glossy Black Cockatoos, Gang Gangs and Feather Tailed Gliders who currently dwell and thrive within this area.

The development proposal clearly goes against environmental protection requirements set out in the LEP and DCP for land zoned C4 Environmental Living. It is not ‘low impact’ and will have an adverse effect on the special values we place on an area considered to have ecological and scientific value. Not to mention the aesthetic we pride ourselves on in the ESC - one which values, protects and promotes the natural beauty we have around us.

As a long term resident and part of the local teaching community it saddens me that future generations may be denied the opportunity and privilege of experiencing our areas incredible natural biodiversity as it currently stands.

Thank you for taking the time to consider my concerns, and I sincerely hope that you will uphold our communities environmental standards with regards this and any future development applications.

Clare Dunn
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
22 Azure Avenue Broulee NSW 2537
Multi Dwelling Housing

Have we learned nothing from the North Coast NSW overdevelopment of small towns
Broulee is bursting at the seams
The infrastructure is non existent and developer greed is rife

Chris Doring
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
22 Azure Avenue Broulee NSW 2537
Multi Dwelling Housing

I totally agree with Suzanne meli. Broulee is over crowded now.
A BIG NO!!!

Shirley Bateman-Read
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
22 Azure Avenue Broulee NSW 2537
Multi Dwelling Housing

Absolutely not Broulee can’t handle another multi dwelling housing build the other 80 housed are yet constructed the school is full the beach road is bumper to bumper oaks ranch wants to take initiative on the already approved DA for 200 homes…no!

Suzanne meli
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
4 Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
Strata subdivision

Why the late notification? This has already been built.

Shirley Bateman-Read
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
25 Church Street Moruya NSW 2537
Change of use to food and drink premises (cafe and small bar)

We only recently heard of this project and are very excited by what it will offer the town. We run an accommodation business and these are exactly the type of business that our guests are looking to frequent. Our guests are generally financially secure and are looking for quality places to eat and drink as well as interesting things to do in the area. The proximity to the Riverside park is perfect, especially on market days and will encourage our guests to walk through town to access these areas and spend money in the other shops. We strongly support this application.

M & S Franklin
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Annetts Parade Mossy Point NSW 2537
16 lot residential subdivision

I agree wholeheartedly with Chris Doring and the comment. Catering to money-hungry developers is not acceptable. Keep going with these plans and there will be no bush left.

Shirley Read
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Annetts Parade Mossy Point NSW 2537
16 lot residential subdivision

This proposal is preposterous
This is a small village

Developments of this nature may appropiate in
towns like Batemans but not in keeping with a village atmosphere
I note you have rejected the initial submission
Developers greed

Chris Doring
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
52 Moorong Crescent Malua Bay NSW 2536
Alterations and additions to dwelling and swimming pool

Please advise where swimming pool is located and how close to side fence it is . Also fencing

Caroline Pugh
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
40 Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
CC22/198 - Fit out of Supermarket - D & C Ferguson

Bring on the new supermarket. Will make the iga and other shops step their game up. I fully support the application

Peter Bradshaw
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
80 lot Subdivision

The council will go ahead with their plans, no matter how many disagree. My request, is how about selling these new buyers a DECENT size block of land, and we don’t end building on top of each other. Houses in recent developments have no need for side windows as they could reach out and shake hands with the family next door not much of a view either. Developers, councils need to wake up and have people on bigger blocks.

Shirley Read
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
40 Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
CC22/198 - Fit out of Supermarket - D & C Ferguson

I totally agree with the above responder
This small community is well serviced by the long established Broulee Supermarket plus IGA which is more recently established
This new proposed development into an all ready overcrowded Train St with its parking issues is an example of poor environmental and commercial planning
There is no need to introduce another business into this village enviroment

Chris Doring
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
40 Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
CC22/198 - Fit out of Supermarket - D & C Ferguson

Why is this being proposed? Broulee has a local supermarket. This new development will likely put the small supermarket out of business. We need to support small local businesses not make it impossible for them to survive. I therefore oppose this application.

Sarah Sutcliffe
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
80 lot Subdivision

We too are patiently waiting for a block in this development and look forward to becoming a part of the beautiful Broulee community. I do agree that affordability and environmental impact are important factors to be considered in approving this development.

J&C
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
171 Northcove Road Maloneys Beach NSW 2536
CC210057 - Construction of Double Storey House - Homme Certidiers

I have queries about the development doesn't allow adequate light into my house and blocks all light to my outdoor space - I have written a letter to council but no one has responded

Sharilea Hitchcock
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
80 lot Subdivision

I think that Broulee has experienced enough over development and excessive clearance of natural vegetation in the recent past. What’s the end point for this strategy for development - just another bland suburban environment.

Les Andrews
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
80 lot Subdivision

Please do not destroy the Bangalay forest and the beautiful village of Broulee with more ugly development.

Sarah Sutcliffe
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
17/40 Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
Use of a commercial premise as a supermarket, deli and liquor premise

There is no need for another liquor outlet in Broulee. The fact that it's so close to the local schools is also very inappropriate. Although I don't live in Broulee, my child goes to the school there and my other teenagers hang out with their friends in Broulee a lot.

Pei-Shan Wu
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council
Train Street Broulee NSW 2537
80 lot Subdivision

I have been coming to Broulee for 30 years. I support this development unreservedly. I want my grand children to have an opportunity to buy property and enjoy everything Broulee has to offer - just as we did 30 years ago. We need new generations to live here too - they are Essential for the overall well-being of our wonderful community

Kerry C.
Delivered to Eurobodalla Shire Council